Majestic Theater, West Springfield, MA
through February 16, 2025
by Lisa Covi
A light adult comedy warmed the winter opening night of “Incident at Our Lady of Perpetual Help.” Priming the audience with the setting's early 1970's music, this play presents a devoted and generous Irish Catholic family faced with the ironies and practical dilemmas of changing social mores. The cast's dynamic chemistry evokes both giggles and belly laughs, depicting a family full of contrasting characters, plus their local parish staff.
The story features two pairs of sisters (mothers and daughters) in an Irish Catholic lower middle-class family struggling with economic pressure, opportunities for change, and traditional roles in a close-knit neighborhood where they live and worship and judge each other according to the strictures of the church.
Photo by Kait Rankins |
Burns' character valiantly cajoles the audience with wry observations and idiosyncratic perspective. She convincingly portrays a young woman wrestling with the promises and perils of asserting women's rights in her male-dominated world. At the same time, her story pokes fun at the clash between moral naivete and the illusion of religious social control.
Maggie Hamel, as Linda's younger sister, both motivates "the incident" but tries to inhibit the feared outcome with pluck and innocence that endears the audience to her.
Mother Jo (Sandra Blaney) is the put-upon glue of the quartet, struggling to nurture the family while keeping a cheerful but pragmatic outlook.
Rounding out the inhabitants of the O'Shea's burnt orange kitchen is Father Mike (John Baker) who makes pronouncements blind to the drama unfolding among the women.
The performances are superb, and production values support the effective delivery. Even though the plot follows somewhat predictable paths, deeper themes echo the way people struggle between religious authority, social control, and living with compassion and generosity.
Each female character shows a wondrous strength that imitates the power of the miraculous symbol that names their parish community of Our Lady of Perpetual Help. Their domestic bonds provide the resources for these women to take charge of their destinies.
Katie Forgette's script (premiered in 2019) cleverly provides twists for pacing and propelling the plot. She includes unreliable narrators and a role where a single delightful actor masters four diverse personalities (and genders). The action flies with a running time of two hours, including a short intermission.