Review: Shakespeare & Company, "Mother Play: A Play in Five Evictions"

Shakespeare & Company, Lenox, MA

www.shakespeare.org

through October 5, 2025

by Jarice Hanson

Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright, Paula Vogel, is a national treasure. “Mother Play: A Play in Five Evictions,” her most recent work, is having its New England Premiere at Shakespeare & Company. The semi-autobiographical work is layered with meaning and goes beyond most memory plays to effectively chronicle 40-years of American history and culture as experienced by an American family. 

 

Tamara Hickey plays Phyllis, a single mother. She smokes and drinks to cope with her depression. She has a low-wage job and can only afford for rent of a caretaker’s basement quarters in an apartment building. Carl, played by Eddie Shields, is 16 and bright. He looks forward to a full scholarship in college, while daughter Martha, played by Zoya Martin, is instructed to study typing in high school so she’ll “always be able to support herself.” 

 

This is a family experiencing the dissolution of the nuclear family. Within the opening minutes of the 95-minute play, the audience is left to wonder if the children will ever succeed, or if they will repeat their mother’s “mistakes".

 

Photo by Nile Scott Studios

The subtitle of the play, “A Play in Five Evictions” is an important hint that signals the trio's development as each, in their own way, strives to become self-realized. Like every family, there are fun times, but there are painful times. The brother and sister form a tight bond, in part to support mother, but also to survive her. 

 

A challenge for the three actors in the play is for each of them to age four decades from the play’s beginning in 1962 to shortly after the beginning of the 21st century.

 

Beautifully communicated physically and emotionally by the actors with the aid of clever costumes by Arthur Wilson, delightful choreography by Susan Dibble, and a timeless set by Omid Akbari, the family shows that they may not be able to address honesty collectively, but that honesty, loneliness, and self-determination are values that one must negotiate to become a “whole person.” 

 

Director Ariel Bock keeps the story driving forward until the inevitable conclusion that is both heartbreaking and very real. 

 

This play is multi-layered with something to touch the hearts of every audience member. While there is undeniable sadness and survival portrayed, the trio become representative of changing times, social and economic unrest, and most of all, changing social norms. The audience can't help but feel sad, seeing this mother and her children try to support each other while destined to disappoint, but there is hope in realizing that even dysfunctional families can come to terms with fate. 

 

The ending of the show can be hard for some. While giving the talented actors a well deserved standing ovation, sobs could be heard in the audience. This is a tough emotional show, but well worth the effort to understand, and forgive family transgressions.