REVIEW: Hartford Symphony Orchestra, "Brahms’ First"

The Bushnell, Belding Theater, Hartford, CT

www.hartfordsymphony.org

November 15-17, 2024

by Michael J. Moran

While the third weekend of the HSO’s 2024-2025 “Masterworks” series included only two pieces, both are beloved cornerstones of the standard classical repertoire, and the Belding Theater audience was accordingly large and appreciative.

Inbal Segev

HSO Music Director Carolyn Kuan opened the program with Sir Edward Elgar’s 1919 cello concerto, featuring internationally acclaimed Israeli-born cellist Inbal Segev. Reflecting the English master’s sorrow over the devastation of World War I and the mortal illness of his cherished wife, the concerto was Elgar’s last major work. Segev’s tone was aptly rich and mellow in her opening soliloquy. This was followed by a glowing “Adagio; Moderato,” a light, playful “Lento; Allegro molto,” an elegiac “Adagio,” and a restless “Allegro; Moderato; Allegro, ma non troppo,” including a final, heart-piercing cello soliloquy. Segev’s playing was deeply emotional and technically secure, with Kuan and the HSO offering full-blooded support.

In sharp contrast, Segev’s encore was a joyous account of the closing “Gigue,” a lively Baroque dance, from Johann Sebastian Bach’s 1723 third suite for solo cello, which highlighted her fleet and flawless finger work.

The program ended with Johannes Brahms’ 1876 first symphony. After he was publicly hailed at age 20 by his mentor Robert Schumann as “the savior of German music,” it took Brahms over twenty more years of off and on work to publish his first attempt at the form so highly developed by Beethoven. But his first symphony was an immediate success, one critic even calling it “Beethoven’s Tenth.”

Kuan and the HSO delivered a stirring performance, masterfully shaping the distinctive character of each movement into a dramatic whole, with perfectly judged tempos throughout. The opening “Un poco sostenuto; Allegro” started forcefully and continued with power and warmth. The “Andante sostenuto” was gentle and reflective. The “Un poco allegretto e grazioso” was lithe yet relaxed. The closing “Adagio; Piu andante; Allegro non troppo, ma con brio” was first suspenseful, then majestic, and finally, jubilant. The standing ovation was long, loud, and well earned.

  

The HSO’s next Masterworks program (December 13-15) will feature guest conductor Jonathan Rush and the HSO debut of 2024-2025 Joyce C. Willis Artist in Residence, pianist Clayton Stephenson, in music by Margaret Bonds and Tchaikovsky.