Berkshire Theatre Group. Stockbridge, MA
through June 15, 2025
by Jarice Hanson
The Unicorn Theatre is an intimate space, perfect for staging a complicated play, like "The Elephant Man". Pre-show music gives the opening scene a side-show vibe, so when the lights come up to feature a misshapen mass covered in burlap, there’s little doubt that under that burlap is the central character himself, John Merrick, the fictional personification of the real deformed man who became a side-show novelty in England and Belgium in the later 1800's.
 |
| Photo by Tucker Blair |
Playwright Bernard Pomerance’s 1979 Tony Award Winning play is based on the real Joseph Merrick who, though born with no obvious deformities, grew to become a curiosity because of his physical appearance. The story involves the surgeon, Sir Frederick Treves, who not only saved Merrick from a life of exploitation but gave him a home at the London Hospital; and the people who befriended him during his short life. One of those friends, a stage actress by the name of Mrs. Kendal, introduces him to society and contributes to his growing sense of dignity.
Portraying John Merrick takes an actor with strong physical skills who can develop a rapport with the audience, despite using no prosthesis or special effects to mimic the challenges of Merrick’s disabilities. Actor Michael Wartella creates a creature so believable that when the pictures of the real Merrick are shown on a screen, the audience is witness to the deformities taking shape. This is no spoiler—it is the prelude to the rest of the story, and it creates a bond between the actor and the audience.
Harry Smith as Dr. Treves is believable in his clinical description of Merrick but becomes even more interesting as he learns about Merrick’s intellect, talent, and religious beliefs. As their friendship grows, director Eric Hill uses the growing familiarity to show closeness and respect. Laura Shatkus, as Mrs. Kendal, is a stand-out for her warmth and sincerity as she gets to know Merrick and introduces him to her society friends.
The production is faithful to the accents and mannerisms of the time, but while this is a strength, it also creates a problem. So many different British dialects are used; several audience members muttered about not being able to hear the dialog clearly. Often characters speak while looking upstage, which should not be a problem in a small theatre like the Unicorn, but with the stylized accents and diction, the subtlety of the contrasts that are so pivotal, are lost.
Still, the story of "The Elephant Man" is an important one because it contrasts cruelty toward those based upon appearance and the dignity that is inherent in every human being. It is a relevant play at this time in history, and Berkshire Theatre Group should be congratulated for taking on the challenge.
